Then on smell, Florida Natural smells good. But Minute Maid smells old or sour,,,not good. So Florida Natural wins on "smell".
On "taste", Florida Natural 'not from concentrate' wins by a mile , as Minute Maid tastes sour or "from concentrate" not good.
I did this taste test on Saturday 3 oct 2009 with the Florida Natural "best if used by date of nov 18 o9,,,22:14 17 8". And the Minute Maid date on top is "nov 23 o9 SI 16:52 A ". Try your own side by side taste test. These two were priced 2 for $6 and 2 for $5 at Nob Hill Market, in Capitola ,Ca.